Gold under-eye patches. This is one of those super frivolous things that I would've laughed at 5 years ago but when you have a 2 1/2 year old who still doesn't sleep through the night, they become a necessity. I've tried a few different brands, styles, ingredients (rose, green tea, caffeine, etc) and these 24K gold patches are the best ones. I didn't intentionally try different ones for fun...it's just always "oh time to reorder, let's get these ones because they look good" because I'm buying them anyway and they all cost about the same. This is my 3rd or 4th repurchase of the 24K gold ones. They're a winner.
Pacifier replacements. Because if we run out of pacifiers the not-sleeping-through-the-night might get worse :)
Shiatsu Back Massager. Scott drives a lot. He got this to put in his truck. We tried it out at home and it's pretty amazing. Definitely recommend. The kids love it too because it lights up.
The Boxcar Children. I ruminated for weeks over what my next read aloud book should be at school. In a world of Goosebumps and Dog Man graphic novels, I picked something they'd never pick for themselves. I owned a copy of this once but I think it's at my parents' house.
Stamp pads. This was something I needed but they do not smell as strong as I would like. I have another from a different company that has a great strong grape smell and these aren't as good.
Wet erase markers. Necessary for school. I've found a lot of folks don't know about these. They are so much easier than dry erase for certain surfaces (laminated pages, for instance).
Stickers. I'm not giving out candy this year. It's stickers.
Ruffle socks. Sutton's white ones from last year were too small and also super dingy.
Rosemary Repel kids' hair spray. I read about this on a blog and thought it might be a good idea. I use detangling spray anyway.
Luminex white strips. Loved these. Definitely better than traditional white strips.
Pillow covers. I actually just got these the other day because I realized I wanted to extend the life of the pillows I got recently. They're really nice. Definitely worth it if you need pillow covers.
and a replacement clasp for my fitbit. It took me weeks to order this after mine broke. It was too easy in the end. Mine is pink but they make you buy all of them in a pack.