I can only do so much with a Karin Slaughter book. She's just not for me. This was on some highly recommended list and it was on sale in June so I got it on audio. It was fine, it was twisty, but it was super depressing. More drama than I cared for and too much going on. If you like her books, you'd like it. I think it'd make a good movie or mini-series.
Anatomy of an Alibi by Ashley Elston 2 stars
I didn't mind First Lie Wins, her book two years ago. This one was absolutely thrilling for the first few chapters. Then I didn't care. It went off on a turkey trail with other characters and a whole second plot and I didn't know how I was supposed to keep track of it all. It was weak, to be honest. There was nothing I cared about. The first chapter in particular was REALLY good. I couldn't wait to see where it went and then.....fizzle. Nothing. I'm apparently in the minority though with the Goodreads reviews.
A Wrinkle in Time by Madeleine L'Engle 2.5 stars
We listened to this in the car. Wells liked it well enough.
But. I don't like it. It's famous, sure, but it's actually full of plot holes. And the sci-fi is weak when it comes to visualization. I suppose we could watch the movie (I feel like I told Wells we would do this and then I forgot...). I just don't like it as a book. It's very character-driven, not world-building driven. I didn't know how much more I could take about how hapless and hopeless Meg was and how *clearly* autistic Jamie seemed to be.
The last 1/3 of the book is so rushed after the first 2/3 was so slow, and it's a very unsatisfying ending.
The concept: great. The execution: not. I worry that when we insist books like this are classics that kids must read, we're going to disappoint kids.
The Magician's Nephew by C.S. Lewis 4.5 stars
In case you think I have something against children's classics, I don't. The Magician's Nephew was wonderful. We listened to this on audio. I'd never read it before so I downloaded the entire series of Narnia and this is the only one we got through before I needed a break from kids' books in the car (lol).
This is the prequel everyone needs to read. It's going to be a movie next year and I'm excited for it. I would 100% take Wells to the theater for it. We both really liked it.
C.S. Lewis is such a good writer that there are no plot holes. It's fantasy and it's world-building and it's about characters but it's about the narrative. I could visualize it so I'm excited to see what it looks like on screen (Greta Gerwig is debatable on what she does with films so we'll see).
If you've read or watched The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe, The Magician's Nephew will answer every single question you have about how Narnia came to be. I admit I have not read *past* TLTWandTW in the series, but The Magician's Nephew should be required reading for elementary school.
This is a niche topic but I'm counting it. I read Making Words Stick for some summer professional development. It's about best practices on how to teach in alignment with the Science of Reading. I highly recommend if you are a teacher of any grade level or a parent of young kids.
Her Pretty Face by Robyn Harding 4 stars
I like Robyn Harding books. They, I think, usually take place in Washington state. Some say that they are over-the-top but I think I've read them all now and I enjoy them a lot. The story moves along quickly enough, there's more showing than telling, they're twisty without being tropey. I recommend this. It's on Kindle Unlimited. This one is about a mom who doesn't fit in and makes friends with the most popular mom at the school. It goes layers and layers deep though.
Lies, Lies, Lies by Adele Parks 3 stars
This was a crazy story. Also a domestic thriller in the UK, told from multiple POVs and it was layers deep. You don't really understand the meaning of everything until you get to the last quarter of the book. I recommend, but there's a lot being thrown at you in this book.
The Wrong Daughter by Dandy Smith 4 stars
A UK thriller but much more involved and has a bit of true crime culture added to it. This one requires you to just suspend your belief a bit but it's one of those stories where no one is who they seem. I recommend it for a twisty-turny read.
Ask for Andrea by Noelle W. Ihli 5 stars
Ugh, so good. This was such a sad story but such a GOOD book. Everything about it: the multiple POVs that tie together, the title actually has meaning, and the characters. There were moments where it reminded me of Intensity by Dean Koontz. It was a thrill-ride I had to finish in one sitting. Some of the supernatural bits got to be repetitive but I don't usually do supernatural elements in my books so that's a preference thing.
Whoever edited this book did their job very, very well. I read it in one day.
Forget You Saw Her by Noelle W. Ihli 4 stars
The prequel to Ask for Andrea. Also good. Very sad altogether. Again, lots of supernatural elements but the narratives and the multiple POVs all come together and serve a purpose in the end. At the moment, I'm blanking on the title's poingnantness. I don't know if there's a deeper meaning behind it.
My Husband's Wife by Alice Feeney 3 stars
I've had this hardcover from BOTM since spring. Mav chewed it up a bit. I finally sat down to finish it after I've seen it recommended over and over again on social media.
It definitely pulled me in once I got going. It was interesting the way the characters came together in their storylines but.....I think she threw a dart at a trope wall and hit the square that said "everything, all at once". It was too much. I was left confused at the end.
My favorite by Alice Feeney will always be His & Hers...it's on Kindle Unlimited if you haven't read it!
It Could Have Been Her by Lisa Jewell 4 stars
I am a Lisa Jewell stan. This felt like it was a combo of plot points from Then She Was Gone and The Family Upstairs, both 5-star recommendations from me in years past.
I really did enjoy it but there was a lot going on. I can see how some reviewers were left confused or like they just got hit over the head with a bingo board of plot points. It was a very busy book. Non-linear timelines and multiple POVs within the timelines: Good luck.
But, really, I liked it.
.png)
























































